The following story exemplifies the human spirit at its best, and provides an example of the kinds of things communities can achieve when they bound together to overcome adversity. The sky really is the limit, and as Doe Bay Internet Users Association founder, Chris Sutton, defiantly proclaims:
I think relying on corporate America to come save us all is just not going to happen, but if we all get together and share our resources, communities can do this themselves and be more resilient.
Here are excerpts from the excellent ArsTechnica article, How a Group of Neighbors Created Their Own Internet Service:
When you live somewhere with slow and unreliable Internet access, it usually seems like there’s nothing to do but complain. And that’s exactly what residents of Orcas Island, one of the San Juan Islands in Washington state, were doing in late 2013. Faced with CenturyLink service that was slow and outage-prone, residents gathered at a community potluck and lamented their current connectivity.
“Everyone was asking, ‘what can we do?’” resident Chris Brems recalls. “Then [Chris] Sutton stands up and says, ‘Well, we can do it ourselves.’”
Doe Bay is a rural environment. It’s a place where people judge others by “what you can do,” according to Brems. The area’s residents, many farmers or ranchers, are largely accustomed to doing things for themselves. Sutton’s idea struck a chord. “A bunch of us finally just got fed up with waiting for CenturyLink or anybody else to come to our rescue,” Sutton told Ars.
Faced with a local ISP that couldn’t provide modern broadband, Orcas Island residents designed their ownnetwork and built it themselves. The nonprofit Doe Bay Internet Users Association (DBIUA), founded by Sutton, Brems, and a few friends, now provide Internet service to a portion of the island. It’s a wireless network with radios installed on trees and houses in the Doe Bay portion of Orcas Island. Those radios get signals from radios on top of a water tower, which in turn receive a signal from a microwave tower across the water in Mount Vernon, Washington.
Unlike many satellite and cellular networks, there is no monthly data cap for DBIUA users.
The DBIUA paid StarTouch Broadband Services about $11,000 to supply a microwave link from a tower on the mainland to a radio on top of Doe Bay’s water tower. The water tank, at about 50 feet, is the only structure that’s high enough to create a point-to-point link to the mainland. It is owned by the Doe Bay Water Users Association, which let DBIUA install the radios and other equipment.
Sutton and friends set up Ubiquiti radios throughout the area, on trees and on top of people’s houses, to get people online. Sutton used Google Earth to map out the paths over which wireless signals would travel, and then the team conducted on-the-ground surveys to determine whether one point could reach another.
There are now about 200 radios spread throughout the coverage area, and each homeowner who pays for service has a Wi-Fi router in the home to access the Internet.
Though DBIUA’s Internet service is a rarity, there are similar projects elsewhere. Brooklyn Fiber in New York was founded by two brothers to sell Internet access to the community. A volunteer project called the Red Hook Initiative buys Internet service from Brooklyn Fiber in order to provide free Wi-Fi.
In Germany, residents of a small town called Löwenstedt built their own Internet service. One Ars reader who lives in Norway personally installed fiber lines to his own property.
“There’s actually a thriving global network of community wireless initiatives—many of whom stay in regular touch and swap information on recent software advances, promising hardware, and innovative business models,” Sascha Meinrath, X-Lab founder and Penn State telecommunications professor, told Ars. There are such projects in Austria, Spain, and Greece, and another that serves tribal reservations outside San Diego, he noted.
I covered some of these in the 2013 post: Meet The Meshnet: A New Wave of Decentralized Internet Access
DBIUA spent about $25,000 in total to build the network, and an anonymous resident provided the money in a 3-year, interest-free loan. Residents paid $150 to become members of the DBIUA and $75 a month for Internet service, which goes toward paying down the loan. The monthly fees also cover the $900 a month DBIUA pays StarTouch for bandwidth.
DBIUA needed 25 customers to pay the bills and stay afloat. At 50 now, the organization is paying the loan off a bit more quickly. Sutton hopes to lower the monthly price residents pay after the loan is paid off.
This is such a wonderful example of what a community of people voluntarily working together to help one another can accomplish.
“We’re not making any money here, we’re just covering our costs,” Sutton said. Besides residents, DBIUA also provides Internet access to the water plant and the Doe Bay Resort. The water plant uses very little bandwidth, and the resort also has a fiber connection to OPALCO, he said. (DBIUA talked to OPALCO about purchasing fiber backhaul, but was unable to get wholesale rates, making it more economical to go with StarTouch, Sutton said.)
CenturyLink promised better speeds over the years “but that never came to fruition,” Sutton said. “Just waiting around for corporate America to come save us, we realized no one is going to come out here and make the kind of investment that’s needed for 200 people max.”
But overall, CenturyLink’s poor infrastructure in Doe Bay is reminiscent of AT&T, which has refused to hook up homes in certain DSL areas where it hasn’t invested sufficiently in network. CenturyLink has gone so far as to tell customers who cancel their DSL service that they will not be able to start it up again, Brems said. “CenturyLink said, ‘we’ll take it off, but you’re never going to get back on.’”
With all the success, people in other parts of Orcas have since asked Sutton to set up networks for them. “I’m like, ‘no, but I can tell you how to do it,’’’ he said. So although networks like DBIUA’s remain rare for now, Sutton believes it can be duplicated in more places than you’d expect.
“I think so many other communities could do this themselves,” he said. “There does require a little bit of technical expertise but it’s not something that people can’t learn. I think relying on corporate America to come save us all is just not going to happen, but if we all get together and share our resources, communities can do this themselves and be more resilient.”
For related articles, see:
Meet The Meshnet: A New Wave of Decentralized Internet Access
Meet FireChat – How Hong Kong Protesters are Communicating Without the Internet
The Rise of the Decentralized Web Continues
In Liberty,
Michael Krieger
Donate bitcoins: 35DBUbbAQHTqbDaAc5mAaN6BqwA2AxuE7G
Follow me on Twitter.
The more people take control of their lives like this the better. Small associations are always better, since everyone has a personal connection to everyone else. It is why living in a small nation-state is better. Local farmer’s markets are very popular in my rural area and provide quality products at great prices.
My only complaint is that the spokesman does the usual “corporate America” bashing. Who provided the equipment? The components, design, manufacturing and distribution of the equipment? Is StarTouch a corporation? Very likely. Corporations are not inherently evil. They only become evil when government gives them unlimited power. Corporations do not have a monopoly on force; government does.
The problem now is that government regulates business to such a degree that only large corporations can afford the lobbying necessary to stay in business. Small startups get crushed because politicians pass regulations that favor their donors. Hey, it’s easier to have the government crush your competition than it is to actually compete. We’re just lucky the Internet took off before government had a chance to crush it. If the politicians had their way they would regulate the internet down to a government propaganda machine.
The sooner we can tear down the Leviathan nation-state the better. Unfortunately Boobus Americanus is much too comfortable. Maybe when things get really bad we’ll see a spark of revolution. I keep hoping. But I keep my second passport handy just in case.
I agree with your entire first and last paragraphs, but I have some disagreement with the middle two.
“Corporate America” isn’t a bash of corporations per se; it’s a bash of the increasing control corporations are taking of our governments.
And believe it or not, those lobbyists are hired by the large corporations to implement complex, confusing and costly regulations because 1) it makes regulatory oversight and enforcement difficult and time consuming, 2) it serves to either eliminate or take over the smaller ones and to crush any startups, and 3) it is a handy scapegoat when a large corporation is in the spotlight for illegal actions. Once these corporations completely own the market, then they push for deregulation, blaming government for those regulations.
Yes that’s all fine and dandy except that before they installed the broadband they had a wifi free environment. Now they can all develop cancer while they watch box sets. Smart.
Maybe someone can sell them some tinfoil hats to protect them…
Neil S: (for some reason I can’t reply to your reply)
We don’t disagree at all. What you describe is exactly what happens. I know no one likes the term, but words mean things: we live in a fascist nation. The Feds control every aspect of business, while we claim to have “private” ownership. Just because we don’t have brown shirts in the streets doesn’t mean we have not adopted a fascist economic model. The brown shirts come later.
What I don’t like is lumping all corporations into the evil bin. A corporation is nothing more than a group of people organized by necessity to deal with government regulation. Government tells you how to dance and plays the music. It’s their way or the highway. They determine who succeeds or fails. Corporations are doing what you would do if you could. When the government controls your ability to earn a living, you do anything you can to get government on your side. People think they are doing that by voting but the politicians could not care less what the hoi polloi thinks.
The internet was lucky that they moved so quickly that Leviathan could not react. It won’t last. Politicians are complaining all the time that there is too much freedom and it needs to be controlled. Mike posts these stories all the time.
What happened in this story is what could happen everywhere in any business transaction if the government was not involved. Don’t like what a company offers? Do what these folks did. It’s called freedom. These folks are lucky there is not some sort of government imposed monopoly on internet service in their area.
An example that’s coming: taxes on solar panel owners to be given to the electric utilities for their lost income. The solar providers are not big enough to counter the mega-sized utilities who have been feeding the politicians for decades.
Until the present system is destroyed it will continue to devour us.
“…when you see that in order to produce, you need to obtain permission from men who produce nothing…you may know that your society is doomed.” A. Rand